When community boards supported a street-safety proposal, they attached conditions more than half the time.
How boards responded to 391 street-safety proposals put to them, by outcome. Rows: all boards, Manhattan boards, Brooklyn boards, then every board with 10 or more proposals.
- Supported
- Supported with conditions
- Opposed with conditions
- Opposed
Source: Block Party Resolutions Archive
Note: Of 351 supporting resolutions, 183 (52.1%) attached conditions to the proposal. Proposals cover bike lanes, bus lanes, Open Streets, school streets, daylighting, slow zones, traffic calming, plazas and street redesigns. Not shown: 247 resolutions where the board asked an agency for a street-safety change on its own initiative. Brooklyn coverage is mostly 2019 onward; Manhattan runs back to 2001. Failed motions are left out.
Method: Each resolution was labelled from its title and RESOLVED clauses by two independent reviewers (Cohen’s kappa 0.81, 86% exact agreement); an Opus adjudicator settled the 130 disagreements from the full text. “With conditions” means the board tied its position to a specific, quoted change to the proposal itself (“provided that”, “opposes unless”); unrelated extra requests do not count. Outcome categories follow the Block Party geo map.