Restoring the commuter tax would raise six times what the CSO reports found for FY27
Estimated annual impact of each IBO budget option next to the savings the Chief Savings Officer reports identified. The $1.7B CSO figure is a multi-year total across all agencies; the FY26 and FY27 rows are single-year figures.
- Chief Savings Officer's (CSO) Reports, 2026
- IBO Budget Options, 2024–2026
CSO figures: All CSO savings figures ($1.7B total, $196.5M FY27 highlighted, $49.6M FY26 highlighted) are from the Office of the Mayor's announcement of the Chief Savings Officer program, March 20, 2026. Individual agency reports have not yet been released publicly.
IBO figures: Represent estimated annual revenue or savings impact. Camera fines estimate assumes no behavioral change; actual collections may be lower if fines deter repeat violations. Façade penalty and MSG figures are NYC Department of Finance/IBO estimates.
Sources: CSO figures from the Office of the Mayor announcement, March 20, 2026. IBO budget options from NYCuriosity, January 5, 2026, based on NYC Independent Budget Office analysis. FY26 city budget ($119.7B) from NYC OMB. Created by Tal Roded · NYCuriosity