Croton was built in five years, and Water Tunnel No. 3 has been under construction since 1970
Years from the start of construction to first water or first service for major New York water and transit projects. Orange bars are water projects and blue bars transit. Dashed bars are projected completion dates, and the dashed line marks 2026.
The water projects of the 1800s and early 1900s each took five to nine years. Water Tunnel No. 3, the City's own water megaproject of the last half-century, began construction in 1970. Its first stage entered service in 1998, its Manhattan leg in 2013, and its Brooklyn-Queens shafts are expected in 2032.
Transit follows the same pattern. The first 1.8 miles of the Second Avenue Subway took ten years to build, and the Gateway Hudson Tunnel, under construction since 2023, is scheduled to open in 2035.
Sources: Croton (construction began 1837, water arrived 1842) and New Croton (begun 1885): NYC DEP; New Croton in service 1890, Wikipedia. Catskill Aqueduct "Construction began in 1907" and "the aqueduct proper was completed in 1916": Wikipedia. Delaware Aqueduct "Built between 1939 and 1945": Wikipedia. Water Tunnel No. 3 construction from 1970, shafts "expected to be completed in 2032": Wikipedia. Second Avenue Subway Phase 1, construction April 2007, opened January 1, 2017: Wikipedia. Gateway Hudson Tunnel, construction from 2023, new tunnel scheduled for 2035: Wikipedia.