New York's death rate rose after Croton opened and fell for good only in the 1890s
Crude death rate, deaths per 1,000 residents, New York City, 1804–1920. Dashed lines mark the arrival of Croton water (1842) and the creation of the Metropolitan Board of Health (1866).
The deadliest years came after the aqueduct. Cholera returned in 1849, 1854 and 1866, when Irish and German immigration was crowding lower Manhattan and the city still had few sewers. Haines finds that baseline mortality was rising across American cities before the Civil War, even as their economies grew.
Croton was the precondition. Abundant water made sewers, street cleaning and household plumbing possible, while the Metropolitan Board of Health, created by the State in 1866, and later filtration and chlorination turned that water into lower death rates. Nationally, clean water accounts for nearly half of the drop in big-city mortality from 1900 to 1936 (Cutler and Miller, 2004).
Source: Michael Haines, The Urban Mortality Transition in the United States, 1800–1940, NBER Historical Paper 134 (2001), Figure 1. Haines compiles New York City vital registration from the City Inspector's and Health Department reports and Rosenwaike's Population History of New York City (1972), and notes "serious mortality peaks, notably from the cholera epidemics of 1832, 1849, 1854, and 1866."
Method: the paper prints the series only as a chart. Each yearly value here was read from the coordinates of the chart's plotted points in the PDF and mapped to its axis (10 to 50 deaths per 1,000), so values are approximate. The period averages in the text are the author's arithmetic on those values.