Croton cost almost five times what the State first authorized
Cost of the Croton Aqueduct as authorized, estimated and spent, millions of nominal dollars, 1834–1843. Hollow points are estimates, and the filled point is money spent.
A 4.6-fold overrun did not stop the project. The estimate nearly doubled within a year of the 1834 act and more than tripled by 1837, as the engineers settled on a masonry conduit, the reservoirs and a high bridge over the Harlem River. The City kept borrowing through its Water Stock bonds and finished the work.
In today's terms: $11.45 million in 1843 equals about $501 million by consumer prices, $7.45 billion by production workers' pay and $210 billion as the same share of the national economy (MeasuringWorth, 2024). The share-of-economy figure shows the scale of the commitment for a city of about 312,000 people.
Sources: 1834 authorization, 1835 estimate by chief engineer David Bates Douglass and 1837 Water Commissioners' estimate: Edward Wegmann, The Water-Supply of the City of New York, 1658–1895 (1896), chapter on the Croton Aqueduct. July 1842 Commissioners' estimate ("nearly 9,000,000 of dollars" to the distributing reservoir) and the total cost to April 1, 1843 ($11,452,619.61): Charles King, A Memoir of the Construction, Cost, and Capacity of the Croton Aqueduct (1843). Wegmann puts the cost at about $12 million at completion of High Bridge in 1848.
Comparisons: MeasuringWorth relative value calculator, $11,452,620 in 1843 converted to 2024.