Manhattan's population grew 2.6 times in the 20 years after Croton water arrived
Residents of New York City (Manhattan) at each decennial census, 1790–1900. The dashed line marks 1842, when Croton water reached the city.
The steepest climb came right after the aqueduct opened. The city added about 500,000 residents between 1840 and 1860, more than in its previous 200 years combined, while daily water use rose from 12 million gallons in 1842 to 40 million by 1850.
Water was a precondition, not the only cause. The Erie Canal trade, immigration from Ireland and Germany and the port all drove the growth. Croton made it possible to house and protect that many people on one island.
Sources: U.S. Census Bureau, Population of the 100 Largest Cities, 1790–1990 (Gibson, 1998), Tables 2–13, for 1790–1890, and the same paper's notes for individual places for the 1900 Borough of Manhattan count.
Boundaries: the Census Bureau's "New York city" was New York County until the 1874 annexation of the western Bronx, and the 1880 and 1890 figures include that area. The consolidated five-borough city counted 3,437,202 people in 1900, and Manhattan's figure is shown for continuity.