New Yorkers used 15 times more water in 1894 than when Croton opened
Average daily consumption of Croton water, millions of U.S. gallons, 1842–1894, against the old aqueduct's safe maximum and the New Croton Aqueduct's capacity from 1890.
Demand caught up with the aqueduct in about 30 years. Daily use passed 90 million gallons in the 1870s, close to the 95 million the old conduit could safely carry, so the City built a second, larger aqueduct, the New Croton, which began service in 1890 with three times the capacity.
Each system was a bet on future growth. The Catskill system followed in the 1910s and 1920s and the Delaware system by 1965. Today the City's reservoirs supply about 1 billion gallons a day.
Sources: Edward Wegmann, The Water-Supply of the City of New York, 1658–1895 (1896), consumption table p. 107 and the capacity table in the introduction (72 million gallons a day for the old Croton Aqueduct's design maximum and 302 million for the New Croton Aqueduct). Current supply: NYC Department of Environmental Protection, Water Supply.
Units: U.S. gallons. Nineteenth-century reports sometimes give imperial gallons (1 imperial gallon is about 1.2 U.S. gallons), which Wegmann converts to U.S. gallons.